13 reasons why 2 rape scene trial#
The way that Hannah’s romantic and sexual history was used against her in Bryce’s trial the way that Jess’ vulnerability as a result of alcohol placed the responsibility of her own rape on her shoulders. What the rape scene achieved, however, was to remedy the ills of the characters’ narratives around rape leading up to that point. I don’t agree with the sequence of events after the rape. We need to ask ourselves why we are disgusted He was raped on screen, like two other characters, neither of whose attacks got anywhere near the same level of disgust and outrage. While technically true, synonyms only detract from the message. A lot of the criticisms have skirted around the issue, saying that Tyler was sodomised. So why is a scene where a woman is raped is any more acceptable than a scene involving a male victim? Has female sexual violence become so commonplace that we’ve become immune to it, and the shock factor emerges from the fact, for once, there’s a portrayal of sexual violence against men? We need to ask ourselves why we are disgusted, why we feel that a man being raped is any more horrific than a woman.
![13 reasons why 2 rape scene 13 reasons why 2 rape scene](https://mediaproxy.salon.com/width/1200/https://media.salon.com/2018/05/13-reasons-why.jpg)
Neither of the rapes in season one – Hannah’s or Jess’ – got the same sort of backlash as Tyler’s did. Their faces are in shot so we can see their emotions. They’re both assaulted from behind, held down. There are parallels between Hannah’s rape and Tyler’s. Rape scenes with artistic videography, dim lighting, and smoke and mirrors detract from the sickening, violent reality of rape. The irony seems to be lost, then, that that’s the reality of sexual violence. Much of the criticism revolves around the sheer brutality of the scene, that it’s gratuitously violent and scarring. I realised my knee-jerk disgust was exactly why it was necessary He rapes him because it serves to humiliate and demean Tyler, and because, simply, he can.
![13 reasons why 2 rape scene 13 reasons why 2 rape scene](https://static.onecms.io/wp-content/uploads/sites/6/2019/08/13-reasons-2000.jpg)
Monty, an overtly homophobic character, doesn’t rape Tyler because he finds him attractive, or because his advances were rebuffed, or because Tyler’s unconscious and vulnerable. In a season that revolves around a trial that victim-shamed Bryce’s victims – dismissing their experiences because they’d been drunk or high, or had gotten into the hot tub willingly, or continued to stay loyal to their rapist because they loved them – the bathroom scene served as a reminder: rape isn’t about sex. The third time? I realised my knee-jerk disgust was exactly why it was necessary. The second time, my stomach dropped and I felt physically sick. I caught the last few moments and wound it back because I couldn’t quite believe what I had just seen. The first time I watched the scene, I wasn’t paying attention. Monty, revealed to have been tormenting those on the tapes, violently assaults Tyler before raping him with a mop handle. Much of the new criticism centres around a scene in the finale involving Tyler, recently reformed and placid after a stint in a diversion programme for troubled teens.
13 reasons why 2 rape scene series#
There’s been controversy swirling around 13 Reasons Why since the first series was released last year, and this season has been no different.
![13 reasons why 2 rape scene 13 reasons why 2 rape scene](https://queerty-prodweb.s3.amazonaws.com/2018/05/4C88F6AF00000578-5759061-image-m-40_1527020395904.jpg)
The following article contains explicit discussion of rape.